What we share with others

Friday, April 15, 2016 Permalink

Last week I wrote about a podcast in which Elizabeth Gilbert spoke to Brene Brown about creativity, failure and everything in between.

I was particularly interested in something Brene mentioned towards the end of that podcast about sharing with others, and how we decide what we share.

Sharing the stories of others

In the Magic Lessons podcast series, Liz Gilbert also talks to Cheryl Strayed (author of Wild) about sharing the stories of others. Strayed was probably a bit more reserved than Gilbert and that was something I appreciated.

When blogging I’ll occasionally mention ‘a friend’ or someone I know but try hard not to write about something that isn’t MY story to tell. Strayed and Gilbert talk about secrets and the need to consider who might be hurt by our words. I see a lot of people make inappropriate comments on social media… about their workplace or colleagues or about their relatives. I did a big Facebook friend cull last year in an attempt to keep my personal account limited to those I know and trust, but still…

oversharing with others

I know there’s often a lot of debate about sharing pictures of our kids on non-private social media platforms or blogs and the like. Not something – thankfully – which I’ve had to consider.

I’ve been caught out a couple times with family stuff I’ve shared online without asking; but usually I TRY to ask someone’s permission before I share their picture or story. (Well, except for my mother, cos I’m fairly sure publicly making fun of her hoarding tendencies helps make the world a better place!)

Sharing our own stories

What interested me the most in the Gilbert / Brown podcast however, was Brene’s comment about what she shares about herself.

She talked about owning or orphaning our stories.

She firstly suggested we ONLY share with those who’ve earned the right to hear our stories.

I like that concept generally and it makes sense. As someone who’s prone to tell a complete stranger their life story, I really need to rein myself in at times.

But she also said we should ensure our own ‘healing’ isn’t contingent on the audience’s response to what we share. She recommended we ‘process’ stuff first.

sharing with others

I’ve often talked about the fact that I find it quite cathartic to blog or write about something that’s playing on my mind. It helps order my thoughts and release them from my mind.

So I wonder… am I doing myself a disservice by sharing stuff that I haven’t ‘processed’. Stuff that’s stressing me out?

And worse still… Brown suggested that sharing stuff before we’re ready is not generous or giving.

Ummmm…. eek!

Because they were talking about creativity and life, I realise Brene wasn’t only talking about our online lives. But I’ve been pondering on this ever since?

Do you overshare?
Where do you stand on sharing stuff we haven’t ‘processed’? (Like the notion of sharing stuff we haven’t processed!) #argh

Flogging my blog With Some Grace today.

26 Comments
  • Sarah @sarahdipity
    April 15, 2016

    It’s an interesting topic, one which I’m not sure I have the answers to. I try to be careful when sharing my parenting stories- I like to be sure that it’s MY story I’m sharing and not my sons. I think it’s up to each individual to decide what they feel comfortable sharing, I don’t think there are any hard and fast rules. But yes, I absolutely think it’s fine to share stuff you’re still processing- for me, writing is often part of the processing, it’s my way to work through things.

    • Debbish
      April 15, 2016

      Yes I’ve always been the same Sarah. There’s a meme I like that says something like…. “I don’t know what I think until I write it.”

      I can very much relate!

      I have a habit of starting a post about something but then get completely turned around midway through!

  • Kathryn
    April 15, 2016

    Love this post Deb. Just happened to be first in line on my Bloglovin’. Must listen to that podcast – soon! I am pretty careful about what I share online. Too careful probably but that is my nature. Are you an extrovert or introvert? I am an introvert, it all goes on inside! I know sometimes we have to talk out to understand ourselves and I guess blogging is one of your ways. However I think processing something online in relatively safe environment is good and as you point out where no one gets hurt.

    • Debbish
      April 15, 2016

      I usually ‘test’ as an introvert Kathryn though it surprises people as I ‘perform’ well with others and can smooch easily. I’m generally find ‘talking’ about anything but to prefer to write.

  • kimbacaffeinate
    April 15, 2016

    I limit what I share for many reasons. As a blogger/reviewer/self-employed media specialist I need to be careful not to offend. I do not believe in sharing drama on social media. I often cringe at the couples who spill all on facebook.

    • Debbish
      April 15, 2016

      I think I sometimes share more than I should on social media because I live alone… so I’ll share weird things about killing a plant or watching something on TV – when (if I had a partner or family members) I’d probably just turn to them and comment. I try really hard not to post as a cry for help but suspect I do it more than I like to think!

  • Sammie @ The Annoyed Thyroid
    April 15, 2016

    Oh, I’m intrigued about that podcast. I feel that blogging is a healthy way for me to process my “stuff” and I am careful to only try and share my own stories, because the stories of others are not mine to share. Facebook is a whole other ball game. I think someone needs to start a sub group called Oversharers Anonymous! I can’t believe the stuff that some peeps put out there. Thanks for giving me some food for thought!

    • Debbish
      April 15, 2016

      No worries Sammie. Liz and Cheryl Strayed’s conversation is in response to one of the people Liz has interviewed…. someone who wants to write a book but their story will also affect those around them. (The person is a blogger and she says that her blogs posts have already upset some relatives.)

      I’ve written about my father occasionally and usually talk to my mother if I’m mentioning anything negative (nothing bad, just his propensity for perfectionism etc…) and occasionally wonder what my brother thinks… (as the other stakeholder in my primary family!).

  • divabooknerd
    April 15, 2016

    Really interesting discussion Deb and one I often talk about with other bloggers actually. From day dot of blogging, I’ve never put myself out there publicly. I know the dangers of sharing too much and you can never get that information back. Talking about yourself and your experiences is in a different category though, it’s less about being safe online and more about opening yourself up to people which makes you vulnerable as well and provided it’s our own story to tell. I worry about teens oversharing mostly, they aren’t as hardened as what we as older adults generally are. I probably share too little, which makes me seem like a bit of a stuck up asshole, but it’s just trying to protect myself so my blog life and life are separate.

    Loved the discussion Deb, so incredibly relevant and wonderfully written <3 <3

    • Debbish
      April 15, 2016

      Awww thanks Kelly. I’ve always been pretty careful to never talk about work on the blog or on social media. I mean, I might complain about being busy or something but I’ve never said where I work or talked about my role.

      I actually liked the freedom of not being in government as I felt I could speak a little more about policy type stuff – something I don’t do usually.

      My own line in the sand (I’ve used for years) is… If I was to ever run for politics, what would and what wouldn’t I want people to know. Some of the stuff I share (about my lack of love life, struggles to lose weight, chocolate addition etc) I don’t worry about anyone knowing. But there’s other (more personal) stuff I keep to myself.

      Having said that… when I was SUPPOSEDLY setting up my online writing business over the last few years (mainly looking for local clients) I realised I’d be referring them to this site. I think that’s when I started to lose my authentic voice a little. I didn’t really want potential business clients reading the shit I share here. If I’m freelancing and pitching to online sites and magazines I don’t mind cos I think the blog helps demonstrate ‘who’ I am…. but local business owners might not get my dastardly blunt sense of humour!).

      Thankfully, now I’m working part-time I don’t need to worry about the local business thing!

  • Margaret Finlay
    April 16, 2016

    I wonder if the caution to ‘not share’ before you’ve processed it yourself, is so you don’t get overwhelmed by suggestions of what you SHOULD do, before you figure it out for yourself. I can see the wisdom in that approach for sure. If you were inviting all and sundry to give an opinion and provide a solution then I can see, depending on the posting individual, how this might be unhelpful. But I’m with you in terms of writing about things can often help figure things out one way or another, and if you’re sensible about it, some people MAY have exceptionally useful suggestions!

    I LOVE Brene Brown, but while I love most of what she says – her empathy/sympathy hang-ups are a point of contention for me personally 🙂

    But wouldn’t it be boring if we were 100% on board with everything 😉

    • Debbish
      April 16, 2016

      I like Brene’s stuff on blame and guilt but know what you mean about the focus on empathy. I know it’s the flipside of guilt, but wonder if there’s something in between.

      And yes, I think that’s it Margaret – getting advice when you’re not ready for it can sometimes be a challenge. For me it’s also helpful. I often don’t know what I think (about my apartment and moving predicament, for example) until someone else makes a suggestion and think… “No, I don’t want that!”

  • Jo
    April 16, 2016

    I really liked the part in that podcast about not making our healing contingent on that. I tend to journal for catharsis- & have been known to write scenes that start life almost as if it’s from my journal, but then become my character’s story. By the time it’s her story, it’s no longer mine & I’ve moved through it. Does that make sense?

    • Debbish
      April 16, 2016

      Yes, that surprised me a bit as it made me ponder the sorts of things I blog about when trying to get them out of my head…

  • charliegirlteachergirl
    April 17, 2016

    I probably do overshare, like any typical person. However, I don’t “bare all” on social media or my book blog. I have started a personal blog that is about my experiences in life, and it is very revealing about who I am and what I’ve been through.

    • Debbish
      April 17, 2016

      The personal blog sounds interesting! I guess you prefer keeping it separate to the book blog, rather than intermingling the posts?

  • Lexxie @ (un)Conventional Bookviews
    April 17, 2016

    You know, Deb, I think Brene was probably using herself as an example for her generalisation, thus, what she said is something you can think about, and then use the parts that feel the best to you. I don’t think there’s one rule fits all in these cases. Some people are good at sharing exactly what they need to share in order for other people to feel like they really know them very well. Other people share things that might be inappropriate to share with some people, but perfect with others – however that also depends on the person listening / reading IMO.
    And so, what one person might think is ‘oversharing’ is the perfect thing for another person to hear or read at that moment. Sharing ourselves with others is an act of trust in some ways, and at the same time with the internet, it is possible to share ourselves with a sort of barrier because we have the screen between ourselves and the other person(s).
    Great post, Deb!

    • Debbish
      April 17, 2016

      Thanks Lexxie and I guess yes, Brene was probably thinking of her own point of view… it’s so subjective isn’t it?!

  • Kristen @ Metaphors and Moonlight
    April 17, 2016

    “She firstly suggested we ONLY share with those who’ve earned the right to hear our stories.” OHMYGOODNESS. This is what I’ve always said!!! But I’ve always felt like no one else ever understood this reason! I’m kind of freaking out knowing there is at least one other person out there who feels the same way. I just always felt like the people who deserve to know what’s going on in my life will know. They won’t need FB or whatever to tell them. And the rest don’t deserve to know.

    But with a blog it’s hard because people want to know the person behind the blog. I love actually learning about who my fellow bloggers are, so I imagine others feel the same. So I do share things sometimes. Except it’s literally a constant struggle because a part of me doesn’t want to share anything because not only will my fellow bloggers see it, anyone in the world can see it. So even if it’s not *personal* per se, it bothers me that now strangers know the story about that one time I went on a trip to XYZ or whatever. Sorry, I’m rambling because I can’t believe I’m not the only person who feels this way lol.

    I also am very protective of other people’s stories. If there’s one thing to be said about me, it’s that I’m trustworthy. I’m big on privacy. So if someone tells me something, I recognize that it’s not necessarily mine to share. And I hate when people do that to me, tell other people personal things that weren’t theirs to tell. So it actually kind of upsets me sometimes when I see people sharing certain personal things about friends and family.

    Ok I think I’ve typed enough lol. Great topic!

    • Debbish
      April 17, 2016

      Thanks Kristen. I guess I use Facebook to keep in touch with acquaintances as well…. old work colleagues, old school friends. People I’ve been close to but don’t see often so I kinda like hearing what they’re up to and suspect they’re the same. But… I guess it depends on where we draw the line. I like to think I don’t overshare TOO much on social media but I’m pretty sure I do. I moan about my apartment, my weight, TV and the like. I don’t think I’d moan there about a friend or work etc as I’m pretty sure it’d get back to the relevant people!

  • Aj @ Read All The Things!
    April 17, 2016

    Great post. I was actually just thinking about this topic. I’m fine with sharing entertaining stories about myself, but I mostly try to leave other people out of it. For a post I wrote last Thursday, I wanted to talk about the bullying that my friend went through in high school, but I didn’t because it’s not my story to tell.

    • Debbish
      April 20, 2016

      I sometimes share stuff about friends if they’re not identifiable. I’ll sometimes change the detail and say… ‘someone I once worked with’ (if it’s actually a school friend), for eg. If the story isn’t too personal (ie. just about something I did on the weekend) I worry less but I never use anyone’s name

  • Trish @ Between My Lines
    April 18, 2016

    Very interesting and it’s fodder for thought. I never share about others but I do share a lot about my own life (on the blog, on snapchat) and it’s interesting to hear that about processing it yourself first. I think this is something to think about and see just how I feel about it. I know I do filter though so it’s not like I put everything out there.
    To be honest, I like that you do put yourself out there on your blog. I find I relate to a lot of it and that then makes your blog have a personality and makes it memorable to me.

    • Debbish
      April 20, 2016

      Oh thanks Trish and I’m impressed you’re snapchatting. My niece showed me how it worked but I just haven’t had the inclination to join yet. Perhaps I could ditch another social media option for it?

      • Trish @ Between My Lines
        April 24, 2016

        Social media eats up far too much of my time but I do love it! I have more or less given up on twitter to make room for it!

        • Debbish
          April 25, 2016

          I note you’re snapchatting. It’s something I haven’t tried yet so must check it out!

I'd love to hear your thoughts