Earlier this month it was World Childless Week. Who knew that was even a thing? I wouldn’t have if I hadn’t seen some articles on social media via Australia’s national broadcaster, ABC which published some great pieces supporting the week and sharing people’s stories.
The thing that hit home most for me – in the articles themselves and in the comments that followed – was the very important distinction between being childless vs being childfree.
Basically it’s broadly defined thus:
Childfree – those who voluntarily choose not to have children
Childless – those who want to have children but are unable to do so
I’m in the latter category in case you wondered. I always wanted to have kids. When I was young I wasn’t at all ambitious. I grew up assuming I would: get married and have kids. Full stop. I thought little about a career. I mean, I knew I’d need a job. Both of my parents worked – had jobs rather than careers or professions and I knew it was a necessary evil.
But even though I went to university I still didn’t really think much about my ‘career’ long-term. I liked the idea of being financially secure, even ‘well off’ but when I pictured my life it was all about my husband and kids.
Like many – I’d grown up on a diet of fairytales – so I assumed I’d meet the man of my dreams, get married and have kids. I didn’t factor in the increasing number of challenges people face: meeting the right person; fertility issues; or being able to afford a family. Let alone, divorce or separation.
I was 41 before I realised I might not ‘eventually’ meet THE ONE. There’d been no near-misses. No long-termers who didn’t quite make the cut.
So I went it alone, despite the fears of my family. The fertility specialist I saw didn’t recommend going straight to IVF. I wasn’t actually ‘infertile’ she said. I’d never tried to get pregnant. I was ‘socially infertile’, which sounds like a horrible disease to suffer.
So, several insemination attempts later I gave up for a bit. I was procuring donor sperm from the US for $950 / pop, so it wasn’t IVF-expensive, but it wasn’t cheap.
A couple of years later I tried again. This time down the IVF route, but some early tests indicated I was very very unlikely to become pregnant. I was 43 now and had to decide how far I was willing to take things. It was a pretty devastating period. Everyone else seemed to be pregnant. And able to become so at the drop of a hat – or at least via regular sex with a partner. I became slightly obsessed and rather bitter for a while, as those desperate for children are wont to do.
In the end I decided to stop trying. It felt like it gave me some semblance of control after a couple of roller-coaster-like years. But it was devastating nonetheless. The fact that I couldn’t seem to find my place in the world – not part of a couple, not a parent (and later not going to be a grandparent) – is certainly the topic for another time but then… in 2011 it meant life – as I’d always assumed it – was not to be.
I tried to imagine the next 40ish years rolling out before me as it currently was. Work and little else. Catching up with friends (who were partnered and had families) when they were available. And did I mention work?
The turning point for me was the death of my father later that year and then a redundancy the next year. All of which led to me making a seachange.
My life direction changed, but it doesn’t mean I’ve completely come to terms with the route it’s taken. It hits home when you least expect it. And I suspect it will continue to do so.
** Photo by Juan Manuel Sanchez on Unsplash
September 29, 2021
Thanks for sharing this, Deb. I’m glad the term ‘childfree’ is used more and more these days because it’s something I’ve known about myself for a while (late twenties, early 30s?) and it doesn’t seem appropriate to lump us in the same category as those who have suffered miscarriages and grief over not being able to have one. I have friends who have gone through IVF unsuccessfully and it’s so hard. I understand it would be for you as well. And as you said, you might be okay most of the time but then there will be moments where it hits again. Be gentle with yourself.
September 30, 2021
Thanks Sanch and yes I think it’s an important distinction but I suspect some of the ‘fallout’ (wrong word I realise) or what we deal with later would be similar – ie. I mentioned the notion of finding your tribe and those with whom you have stuff in common. I think there are certain stages in life when it’s hard to do that when friends are grappling with a young baby, or kids are starting school, finishing school, getting married or grandkids are on the horizon.
September 29, 2021
Deb, I read this earlier and now back to comment after thinking more on your post. Firstly I am so sorry you were not able (as it seemed) in the end to have a child. Secondly that life has been so tough as you have managed the roller coaster of many emotions. I am in awe of your courage and willingness now to share. It’s a revelation for me about you. I similarly thought I would always have children, and due to a very “mistaken idea that going off the pill for a break was a good plan” I became pregnant “just like that” at 21. I then married her dad, and still with him…as you know but I rarely shared much of the heartache of “trying” for Baby #2, until I finally did so in Telling My Story. For well over 4 years I was given many “medical and other reasons – too fat for one” by so-called specialists about why no Baby #2…and anyway, we ended up with him because a more thorough OBGYN found I had multiple cysts which had prevented fertilisation. But that’s not what I wanted to end on…I more than anything wanted you to know this must have been (and now in sharing with such candour) and huge event in your life…then Dad’s dying and your redundancy. Gosh. As our friend Sanch says : Be gentle with yourself…love D
September 30, 2021
Ah yes… I was reminded recently how – during that time – I used to pour through Kmart / Target catalogues, not just choosing what clothes, change tables etc I’d buy but I’d look at the kids and wonder what mine would look like.
I struggled when I didn’t get pregnant after a few attempts and felt really frustrated (angry?) to see so many other pregnant people – when my issue wasn’t infertility as such, but mostly age and lack of opportunities – I used to complain to some friends and I still remember one saying to me that my attitude ‘disturbed’ her. I’m not sure if she chose the word lightly or on purpose but it’s obviously stuck with me for well over a decade so I think I felt it was wrong to feel duped or as if the situation was unfair.
September 30, 2021
Oh. Yes of course it would be so hard and that person’s comment, triggering what it did in you (would have me too !) was so wrong. I am sorry, this has been really awful…and in some ways, I hope that sharing with more like this may “help” you see & feel that you not only were having feelings of huge significance to you but that others’ discomfort (!) May have been why you might have been tempted to push those feelings and times away. This 10 year anniversary of your Dad’s passing has been a time when you have reflected I can see…l
September 30, 2021
Thanks for your honesty Deb. Kind of had me weeping into my weeties, but that’s what happens when I find out something devastating about someone I like. I have no platitudes, just a cyber hug to offer. xo
September 30, 2021
Oh thank you for that Theresa. Thankfully I’m well past the ‘begrudging others’ stage now. I was 43 when I gave up, partially so I got to be the one to decide (and felt less victim-like) but also realising I was going to be doing it on my own and wasn’t getting any younger. I still remember, while making the decision, seeing a mother carrying a toddler around a nearby park on her shoulders and thinking… ‘Oh my god, I couldn’t do that in a few years time!’
Now it hits home more cos of the lack of legacy (I’ve written about that before) – it ends with me. And the whole ‘tribe’ thing. I’m getting closer to the age of friends whose kids are marrying and having babies and often that means their priorities change again.
October 4, 2021
Thanks for sharing this, Deb. I didn’t know about World Childless Week. I’m sorry you had to go through the roller coaster. Virtual hugs to you. #lifethisweek
October 4, 2021
Thanks Natalie. x
October 4, 2021
It’s such a hard one Deb – we take our fertility for granted for so many years, and then for some it becomes the biggest source of heartache. When we were young and pregnant, one of my closest friends was struggling with not being able to “join the club” and my heart broke at how insensitive I’d been (I didn’t know they were having problems) it’s so easy for some and so difficult for others.
Our daughter and SIL have decided to not have children – they both wanted them and then changed their minds because they love their childfree life. They’re in their early 30’s now (married for 9 years) but I sometimes wonder if they assume they’ll still have the choice available in the next 9 years if they change their minds.
That being said, there’s also a lot to be said for a childfree life – my son and DIL often comment on how good our daughter’s life is without the hassel of little kids, snotty noses, nappies, noise, less money etc…… I’m just sorry you didn’t get to choose and to have your heart’s desire though. xxxx
October 4, 2021
Ah yes, I think the most challenging thing I dealt with was the friends who told me how lucky I was to be child-free…. when it wasn’t a choice. Of course I knew raising kids wasn’t easy and was fraught but I know very few people who regret their child!
October 4, 2021
I think the main thing I take from this is choice. You haven’t made a choice to be childless, just things didn’t work out for you along the way and I’m sorry for that.
I remember my daughters talking about the fear of pregnancy early on in their relationships but when they were actually trying for a baby it became more of an issue than they’d previously thought. We also found out recently there is a genetic condition in our family with a 50/50 chance of passing it on to children and it gets more severe as it moves down the generations, so one daughter is now considering IVF to rule out passing on the gene. Another daughter had her baby very early at 25 weeks and is scared about trying again. Life is never smooth sailing for some of us is it?
Thanks for your honesty and explaining the difference between childless and childfree- all very interesting! #lifethisweek
October 4, 2021
I have quite a few friends who found partners late in life so had to go through IVF and a few others who were single or had fertility issues and it really can mess with your head. I’m not sure what I’d do differently. I was so sure I’d meet someone (which happens for most people) I don’t think I wanted to admit I’d given up until I hit my 40s.
October 4, 2021
Thanks for this honest and revealing post. I didn’t realise this had been an issue for you and feel sorry that you had to endure this roller coaster. You really made me stop and think. I had my children at a young age and never gave any thought to not being able to conceive. I also hadn’t thought of the difference between childless and child free. Thanks for sharing this.
October 6, 2021
I think if you’ve not been impacted by something Jen (or know of those impacted) you don’t realise it’s a sensitive issue for some. I’m sure I’m like that about many things I’m not even conscious of.
October 4, 2021
This is a very big post and I need to think about it before I respond. I just wanted you to know that I read it. Very generous share and I think there are a lot of people who will aprreciate it. I will contemplate it for a bit.
October 6, 2021
Thanks Lydia.
October 4, 2021
Thanks for sharing this hard part of your life with us, Debbie. I read this post earlier this week and it made me so sad. Like the previous commenter here, I didn’t know how to respond. I thought of my own choice of being child-free and how I’m satisfied with it – but it is just that, a choice. While I’m glad to see that there’s more acceptance around choosing to not have children these days, reading your post I was also reminded of how hard it must be for people like yourself to be around people who could have children but chose not too, while you and many others with you, wished to have children but couldn’t.
October 6, 2021
It was certainly tough for a while there Susanne. When I was younger I assumed it would still happen and was waiting for my turn and happy for others who were having children. Then… when I realised I had to go it alone or miss out I become hyper-aware of kids and babies and families. I even started getting annoyed at people who talked about ‘when they have grandkids’ or when their son / daughter gets married. “It doesn’t happen for all of us!” I wanted to shout. It’s an assumption we make – as I did – that it’s part of life but for many of us (mine’s mostly a result of being single as I’m not aware of any fertility issues) it doesn’t happen.
Obviously it’s too late (re the children thing) now so I’m more resolved but feel sad about the lack of ‘family’ other than my primary family / family of birth. I think it will hit home a lot more when my mother passes.
October 6, 2021
Hi Deb, I think it’s very brave and wonderful of you to share this on your blog. I’m so sorry life didn’t quite go the way you planned. Perhaps the man upstairs had a different plan for you for some reason? As you might remember, my youngest sister has had the same experience as you (well not exact but you know what I mean). She’s now 46 or 47 (I can’t remember which) and has never met ‘the one’ and has not had any children. She is still single. She dearly wanted children and a husband too. Her childlessness was not a choice. She hasn’t tried to have a child on her own though. She opted to get a little dog. She has a little red toy poodle called ‘Rudi’ who I’m sure you’ve seen me post photos of. It is he who she can unleash a lot of her maternal needs. I dread the day he passes away. He is very loved!
October 6, 2021
I’m not really an animal / pet person unfortunately but I’m sure if I did get a cat or dog they’d be like my baby and I’m not sure my attachment to them would be entirely healthy…. #eek
October 7, 2021
Ah Deb, it was good to see how much your post was read and people commented and I hope by sharing, it’s been OK for you too. Great to have you link up for #lifethisweek. Next week, the optional prompt is Water. See you at Denyse Whelan Blogs then too I hope. Denyse.
October 9, 2021
I don’t think I can really add anything in a comment to adequately further discuss what you raise in the post. What I will say is it’s a really imporant difference between being childless and childfree and I don’t think I fully ever thought about that before, or I sort of merged it as a process. I think being aware of what is (for want of a better word) causing us pain (or discomfort) is important. Even if we can’t change it. I also think demanding people respect our position is equally important – so no dismissing, no assuming. There is a Jack London quote that came up in something I was reading, and I’ve been thinking about it a lot lately. “Life is not always a matter of holding good cards, but sometimes, playing a poor hand well.” So while it doesn’t matter which you are, you need to find a way to find peace with it – however, which you are dictates how you go about coming to terms with it. I fear I’m not explaining myself well, but I’m not meaning a cavallier or dismissive ‘deal with it’. More a ‘it’s going to take contemplative effort if you are able to find peace’. It’s nopt just the thing. It’s like an octopus so it’s a thing and everything else that the tentacles touch or wrap around.
October 9, 2021
True – having a family often defines everything else we do and who we are… whether it should or not. More so obviously while kids are dependent on their parents.
And yes, it’s important to make peace with the lot we’re given in life or we’ll remain stuck and never move forward.
October 9, 2021
And no in that moment of paranoid panic – not saying being child less or child free is a poor hand. That’s just the words in the quote. But we can work with things that are not what we wanted initially.
October 9, 2021
Completely understand. x