Choosing your next read

Saturday, December 5, 2015 Permalink

If I could earn an income from book blogging I’d be one very happy chappy. I’m fortunate to be paid for a monthly wrap-up post I do elsewhere, but otherwise this book blogging gig is purely done for the love of it.

Although I do (of course) receive free copies of books to read—which is amazing. If I didn’t need to pay bills, buy vanilla diet coke and stuff I could die happy. 😉 

Nowadays I mostly get listings from bigger publishers: I put in a request and (more often than not) receive the book in question. It’s a weird process as listings come out in advance, so I’ve recently poured through some March catalogues and I never quite know what will arrive in my post-box or when.

Today however I had cause to go onto a site where you ‘search’ for books according to publisher or genre to put in a request. It’s very much like going to the local library or bookshop and being faced with a myriad of choices!

So for the first time in ages I was forced to remember ‘how’ I used to select my reading fodder. It’s not rocket science of course and I’m pretty sure it’s something that varies from person to person… but I thought I’d share my highly-technical process for choosing books to read.

choosing books 2

1. The author

In my blog posts I often talk about my go-to authors. There are those I love and whose books I devour almost religiously and then there are those whose books I try to read. Earlier this week I mentioned that I used to seek out certain authors at my local library (or bookstore). Of course occasionally I’d discover a new author and if they were already established I was in heaven as I had a huge backlist to read through and wasn’t compelled to wait until their next installment was released.

authors

2. Word of mouth

Once upon a time I predominantly heard about books through reviews in newspapers or magazines or on television. However I now read A LOT of book blogs and participate in some ‘link-ups’ on a weekly basis which exposes me to a summary of others’ reading. I try to read 40-50 of those summary posts a week and if I consistently hear good things about a book or author I make a note to check it out. And then of course there are the Aussie book bloggers I know and love and – although sometimes it seems we’re all reading and writing about the same thing – there’s still enough variety out there to get a taste of what’s happening in the industry.

3. The cover

It’s a sad but true fact most of us DO judge books by their cover (and I suspect my single-status reflects that travesty of human nature! 😉 ). As I’m not  a fan of romance I usually steer clear of books with kissing couples or half-naked men on the cover. And cartoon / drawn covers? Not usually my thing as they tend to represent chick lit or similar. Lately however the increasingly-popular-in-the-US book known as the ‘cosy’ (cozy) also seems to feature the quaintly drawn cover. Irrationally (!!) they make me run a mile though I love Agatha Christie who I assume to be a cosy read. It’s all about your personal taste, I guess but unless you love that author or have heard amazing things about it, a cover can make or break a book.

The 'cozy'

The ‘cosy’

4. The backcover blurb

A book’s promotional material is important and we’ve all felt kinda duped when we’ve read a book which was NOTHING like the backcover blurb promised.

As a result, the blurb (or summary) is a bit like the cover. It’s often the final thing standing between us buying or borrowing a book, or not; and I know a lot of self-published authors say writing the blurb is sometimes harder than writing the book.

But… if you haven’t read a review (or blog post) about the book it’s really all you have to go on and more often than not it does offer a fairly good reflection of what’s inside.

5. The art of comparison

I sigh when I see the words “If you loved Gone Girl, you’ll love…” (although now it’s Girl on a Train!) But I do realise it’s a necessary evil and I used to appreciate that my local library had listings of similar authors. I’m not sure how they were developed, and suspect there wasn’t huge amount of scientific analysis undertaken, but they were helpful and I certainly discovered some new authors that way.

In my experience library and bookshop staff are also good at making recommendations based on your reading tastes. They might not read or like the genre themselves but they’re privy to what everyone else is reading or borrowing.

So… that’s how I set about choosing books. What do you look for?

22 Comments
  • Kate W
    December 5, 2015

    Great post! My reading choices are made pretty much in the same way as yours although I do have 2-3 friends that like EXACTLY the same books as I do, so when they say “You’ve got to read this…”I basically drop everything!

    • Debbish
      December 5, 2015

      Oh that’s handy Kate. I’ve bookmarked a few other book bloggers who seem to like similar books to me but don’t mind reading others (with different genre-interests) and I’ve occasionally chosen to include some books I haven’t read (but ones others have consistently liked – Illuminae, for eg) in the blog post I do for Styling You each month.

  • Michelle Weaver (@pinkypoinker)
    December 5, 2015

    I go by #5. If I love a genre or an author I know I’ll like the book. Sometimes they get it wrong though! The best thing for me to do is read the first page. If it doesn’t get me in then then I probably won’t like it.

    • Debbish
      December 5, 2015

      Good idea Michelle! I deleted (edited out) a large part of the post in which I mentioned that I often got sucked into backcover blurbs in my fave genres which are often similar (serial killers, childhood trauma come back to haunt them as an adult, kids gone missing) and I’d take them home but then when I started to read it I’d get through a page before realising I’d read it before. That’s why I joined Goodreads in 2012 – to help me start to track my reading and not re-borrow the same books again and again!

  • Jo
    December 5, 2015

    Much the same way- although I read a lot of chick lit and romantic elements or romantic suspense, I stay clear of scifi & anything where the back blurb is about kids going missing. For me, the first is an author I’ve read before, then the cover, then the blurb.

  • viki
    December 6, 2015

    I choose my books by authors I know or if it is my favourite genre of if my mom recommend s a book as we like the same type of books.

    • Debbish
      December 6, 2015

      Yes… favourite / regular authors is my first criteria as well!

  • Karen Comer
    December 6, 2015

    I always flick through the book, too, and read a page or two at random. If it makes me curious enough to want to know more, I’ll add it to my reading list.

    • Debbish
      December 6, 2015

      Oh, sounds like a good idea Karen but your bookshop / library visits must be longer than mine used to be! 🙂

  • Bec
    December 6, 2015

    I usually go for mystery/suspence, next step is weeding out the very dark, sinister or overly violent. I have my “go to” reviewers to get some ideas.
    When I used to work 12 week contracts in outback Queensland I’d find the library, when I’d read all I fancied I’d have trouble even choosing a book to pick up and browse, my er, system then was to have a colour of the day, so I’d go for pink books, next day, blue you get my meaning! You can’t be scientific methodology

    • Debbish
      December 6, 2015

      I used to be (and still am) exceedingly fussy. Many a time I would leave my local library without a book in hand after spending an hour or so trying to find something which piqued my interest.

  • Jess
    December 6, 2015

    Great post! I totally judge a book by it’s cover!

    • Debbish
      December 6, 2015

      Perfectly legitimate when it IS a book! 🙂

  • Teddyree
    December 7, 2015

    Similar to yours … favourite authors, bloggers with similar tastes, favourite genres and publisher lists but I’m also a cover whore. Sometimes this results in an epic fail and said book goes on the donation pile 😉

    • Debbish
      December 7, 2015

      I’m probably less convinced by covers in a positive sense – they (solely) rarely tempt me to read / buy a book, but they can easily turn me off!

  • Char
    December 8, 2015

    Yep, that’s how I do it too. Although these days, because I’m reading on a Kindle, the cover has a lot less to do with it than when I was browsing in a book shop. I’ll make my choices because of the author or because of the blurb on the back or because Deb has enjoyed it. That’s right – a lot of my decisions come down to your tastes now. I hope you can cope with the responsibility.

  • Lola
    December 8, 2015

    I mostly use these ones too. Covers can really grab my attention and if a book is by an author I’ve read before or even heard of before there’s a bigger chance I pick up that book. Then ofcourse I look at the blurb and quite often reviews as well, especially with review requests. I feel that reviews can give me a feel for the book and hearing what other people did or didn’t like can really help to make a desicion about whether I want to read a book or not. I am not a fan of comparison though as often they just don’t seem to do a book justice, although I can see how sometimes a comparison can be handy. Great post!

    • Debbish
      December 8, 2015

      Thanks Lola – glad it resonates!

  • divabooknerd
    December 8, 2015

    Ooh, a website that tells you what’s coming out? Sounds like my kind of website. the only time I usually request books is when a publisher has contacted me directly or a call out on social media, and of course they’re only books I want to read. I receive a lot of unsolicited copies which dictate a lot of what I read. Anything that I wouldn’t buy myself, I put aside and donate to other bloggers who want to read that particular book rather than attempt it myself and hate it. When I’m reading my own books, I tend to choose by page number firstly, sometimes I’m int he mood for a longer read, especially if I have a lot of review posts in drafts as it gives me more time to blog and comment.

    I must admit, I’m a bit of a cover tart too. So many pretty books and just not enough time to read them all!

    • Debbish
      December 8, 2015

      I was the opposite and started my review journey via NetGalley Kelly and it took me nearly a year to realise I could request listings from publishers etc and I use NG less now.

I'd love to hear your thoughts