Book review: Burning Mountain by Darcy Tindale

2 min read

One of the things I really liked about her debut novel, The Fall Between was that it reminded me that most crimes are committed by those who are desperate or stupid rather than psychotic or plain evil. Burning Mountain by Darcy Tindale, the second in her series featuring Detective Rebecca Giles, is very much the same. It’s centred around an eighteen year old mystery—the disappearance of a teenage boy—but features those involved in the past and present and reminds us that mistakes or idiotic actions can have unexpected, and dire, repercussions.

Book review: Burning Mountain by Darcy TindaleBurning Mountain
by Darcy Tindale
Series: Detective Giles #2
Published by Penguin Books Australia
on 29/04/2025
Genres: Crime Fiction, Police Procedural
ISBN: 1761049771
Pages: 368
four-stars
Goodreads

In April 2006, fifteen-year-old Oliver went hiking to the lookout on Burning Mountain - and vanished without trace.

His schoolfriends – Bob, Bell, Phil and Paul – were the last ones to see him on the trek, yet the teenagers were never able to explain his disappearance.

Almost twenty years later, Detective Rebecca Giles is called to bushland on nearby Mount Wingen. There a skull has been dug up, reviving the mystery that has haunted the Upper Hunter area for years.

Giles is convinced that they have finally found the missing boy, and that his four friends – all now in their mid-thirties – have always known much more than they revealed. In particular, about the argument that caused Oliver to head down the mountain on his own.

But when she discusses the case with her father, retired Superintendent Benjamin Giles, another suspect is thrown into the mix. One that for Giles is uncomfortably close to home . . .

I hadn’t remembered much about the first book as it was published a couple of years ago and my memory is crap, but on reading my review I recalled the sense of frustration and waste I felt while reading it. And I was reminded that I appreciated that Tindale was writing about the types of criminals who fill courtrooms and prisons around the world rather than those who feature in true-crime documentaries. Again I liked that her characters felt very real and certainly representative of those living/remaining in small towns, without being caricatures. There’s an entire ecosystem at play here where school friendship has morphed into adult relationships. Not to mention school bullies, still hated and throwing their weight around. Even our lead Giles, is walking in her father’s footsteps as a cop on the same turf, years after his retirement.

I’d not remembered some of the other cops we meet here and perhaps a bit of context might have been useful as there were some references to an Inspector who seemed to have an issue with Giles and I wasn’t sure why. And though I liked the introduction of young Joe Thicket (less so his long-suffering mother and abusive father), the convergence of circumstances around his story arc was bittersweet and I did wonder if it was entirely necessary.

But I very much liked the way Tindale slowly picks apart the stories of the kids (now adults) and their families involved in the hike to Burning Mountain almost two decades earlier, slowly revealing lies and half-truths. And in the present continued ill-thought-out ideas end (almost comically) tragically.

Burning Mountain by Darcy Tindale was published by Penguin Books in Australia.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher for review purposes.

four-stars

Discover more from Debbish

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.