Book review: Based on a True Story by Sarah Vaughan

3 min read

Based on a True Story by Sarah Vaughan is the fourth book I’ve read by Vaughan, best known for Anatomy of a Scandal which was made into a series on Netflix. This centres around a family gathered for the 70th birthday of a renowned children’s author amid threats to that author–promising to reveal long-buried secrets that could potentially destroy her career and life–and her three adult daughters all grappling with secrets of their own.

About this book

Book review: Based on a True Story by Sarah VaughanBased on a True Story
by Sarah Vaughan
Published by Simon & Schuster UK
on 31/03/2026
Source: Simon & Schuster
Genres: Crime Fiction
ISBN: 0063457717
Pages: 416
four-stars
Goodreads

Famed children’s author Dame Eleanor Kingman has summoned her family and friends to her exquisite manor house on the cliffs. They're celebrating her birthday—and her latest number one bestseller in her series of books based on a mother fox and her cubs.

But the night before the party, Eleanor receives an email that threatens to expose the lie she’s kept up for over half a century.

Someone knows her secret. Is it her estranged literary agent? Is it her ex-husband, to whom she no longer speaks? Is it the nanny she fired all those years ago, who always did have a knack for storytelling? Or is it one of her three daughters, all of whom have a stake in the publishing empire she has built...

With a television crew arriving to film a documentary of her life, Eleanor needs to find out who sent the email—and preserve her legacy and multimillion-pound career.

My thoughts

There’s an underlying theme here, as the title suggests… around how we define truth; and about ‘fiction’ and its inspiration. Early in the novel at a book event, a young boy accuses Eleanor of lying, saying that her stories are ‘made up’. That’s the point, she tells him, but the child can’t accept that the books have come from Eleanor’s imagination.

‘Telling stories is lying! And liars are bad,’ the kid’s adamant, and his father’s apologetic. The interaction shakes Eleanor more than expected and we learn of the emails she’s been receiving, accusing her of lying… of imposter syndrome. The fact that Eleanor believes their author to be someone from her distant past suggests that there are indeed secrets she’s hiding or (rather) lies she’s adopted or embellished as truth over the years.

We spend time with Eleanor and all three of her daughters (Gilly, Rachel and Delia) but this is preceded by a prologue culminating in the discovery of a body during Eleanor’s 70th birthday celebrations. We then return to the days in the lead-up to the party, as family and guests start to arrive. We learn that, despite a rebellious past Delia, the youngest of the sisters is the apple of her mother’s eye. Both Gilly and Rachel work for their mother so their relationships are somewhat murky and one-sided. We know trouble is afoot because Rachel learns her husband Tom is in debt and wants her to ask Eleanor for money to bail them out; Gilly’s planning on leaving her mother’s employ; and Delia’s got a hidden agenda of sorts.

There’s a lot of backstory fodder here. We learn Delia was the inspiration for Eleanor’s famous fictitious child sleuth, and believes her mother’s forever preserved her as an eight-year-old child. She knows her sisters accuse their mother of favouring her, but she doesn’t believe they realise the heightened expectations and pressure that come with that. As a result, she tells us she’s planning her ‘most potent act of self-destruction’ to be played out during the birthday celebrations.

Adding to the stress of the birthday weekend are uninvited guests as well as the presence of documentary filmmakers, doing a piece about her career with plans to interview Eleanor, family, friends and her agent/s.

We eventually learn of Eleanor’s secrets and Vaughan times the reveal well, but then throws in an added surprise I certainly didn’t see coming… taking us back to the body on the beach.

Vaughan poses some moral or ethical (what-would-you-do?) dilemmas here and there’s a lot of ‘unpack’ in the relationships between the sisters and with their mother, so I think this would be an excellent bookclub read offering much to debate and discuss.

Based on a True Story by Sarah Vaughan was published in Australia by Simon & Schuster in late March 2026.

I received a copy of this book from the publisher for review purposes.

four-stars

Discover more from Debbish

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.